Frequently Asked Questions

Why is it called Evie & Me?

Evelin aka Evie (pronounced Eh-vee) is our daughter! We started this whole shindig after we had her so that we could be together more! If you want to know our full story check out this page

How big are your cookies?

Every cookie is 4 oz. or more, that’s a quarter-pound!

When will my cookies ship?

We bake every Tuesday and Thursday. We ship our cookies out every Wednesday or Friday.

Do you use any preservatives?

We do not use any added preservatives. If you see preservatives in our ingredient list it’s because the ingredient we’re using (like OREOs) already has preservatives.

How long will my cookies stay fresh?

Cookie will stay fresh on the counter for up to a week. If you want to snack on them longer, we suggest putting them in the freezer until you’re ready to eat them, then thaw them on the counter for about an hour.

My cookies are all melty! Are they still okay to eat?

No worries if your cookies arrive melty, the toppings may be messy (we’re sorry!!) but just pop your cookies in the fridge and they’ll be alright.

Can I reheat them?

Pop it in the oven at 350° for about 3-5 minutes to enjoy it how it’s supposed to be. Be aware, anything topped with chocolate or a glaze will melt!

A flavor I want is sold out on your website, how can I get it?

If there is a flavor you’d like but it’s sold out, feel free to reach out on our contact page and I can whip up a batch for you!

I’m allergic to nuts, can I still eat your cookies?

While many of our cookies do not contain nuts, we use nuts in our kitchen and therefore cannot guarantee all cookies are nut-free. We recommend you not consume our cookies if you have a severe allergy.

Do you offer any vegan or gluten-free options?

We do offer a gluten-friendly chocolate chip cookie. We do not offer any vegan options.

Do you do protein cookies?

Nope! We recommend you dunk your cookie in a protein shake - best of both worlds :)

Do you sell decorated cookies?

We don’t offer any decorated sugar cookies but our cookies are gorgeous all on their own, no decoration needed ;)